Trace Clues to a Conclusion
Read the story. Quote clues, explain your inference, and identify its limits. Different inferences are acceptable when the evidence and reasoning support them.
Open worksheet 1 (PDF)I can quote accurate details and explain how they support an inference about a story.
Each form uses a different activity or passage, not just a new worksheet number.
Print page 1 for student practice. The following pages contain explained sample responses. The QR codes and their labels are clickable.
Read the story. Quote clues, explain your inference, and identify its limits. Different inferences are acceptable when the evidence and reasoning support them.
Open worksheet 1 (PDF)Read the mural story. Weigh competing explanations, choose precise evidence, and make a limited prediction. Other well-supported interpretations may be valid.
Open worksheet 2 (PDF)Read the model-building story. Distinguish stated facts from inferences and revise claims that overreach. Acceptable answers must connect specific evidence to reasoning.
Open worksheet 3 (PDF)Use these accessible text versions if a PDF reader is inconvenient. Write your responses on paper; sample responses are kept in a separate expandable section.
Read the story. Quote clues, explain your inference, and identify its limits. Different inferences are acceptable when the evidence and reasoning support them.
Paragraph 1. During the class creek walk, Eli stopped beside a low branch and opened his notebook. 'A nest,' he whispered, writing quickly. Maya leaned closer from the marked path. 'Maybe,' she said. 'I can't see inside it.' Eli looked again, then drew a line through the word he had written.
Paragraph 2. He replaced it with 'woven shape on branch' and sketched the loops he could actually see. Farther along, another student called out that the group had found a nest. Eli raised his hand. 'We found a shape that might be one,' he said. 'We would need more evidence to name it.'
Paragraph 3. Back at school, Maya offered him a photograph taken from the path. Eli slid it beside his sketch instead of writing a final label. Under both pictures he added a question for their next discussion. When classmates hurried to decorate their notebook covers, he kept comparing the two views.
Eli seems to care more about recording what the evidence supports than about keeping his first answer.
Reasoning: First notice that he changes an initial label after looking again. Then connect that change to his later request for more evidence; together they suggest a concern for accuracy.
He 'drew a line through the word' and said, 'We would need more evidence to name it.' He corrects his own claim and explains why certainty would be premature.
Reasoning: First choose an action showing a revision and dialogue explaining its purpose. Then connect both clues to careful evidence use rather than treating the quotations as a complete explanation by themselves.
Eli continues comparing the sketch and photograph while classmates decorate, so his attention to evidence lasts beyond Maya's first comment.
Reasoning: First check what Eli does later, when the immediate conversation has ended. Then explain how his continued comparison supports genuine interest in checking the observation, not just agreement with Maya.
No. The students can see a woven shape, but the story never confirms what it is. Eli compares the pictures and adds a question instead of a final label.
Reasoning: First separate the visible shape from its possible identity. Then use Eli's decision not to add a final label and his request for more evidence to explain why a definite identification is not supported.
Read the mural story. Weigh competing explanations, choose precise evidence, and make a limited prediction. Other well-supported interpretations may be valid.
Paragraph 1. Jalen carried a tray of brushes into the community mural room. He had practiced painting thin borders all week. At the wall, he found Tessa staring at a crooked blue line. She placed her brush in the wash bucket and moved toward the stack of empty supply boxes by the door.
Paragraph 2. 'That edge was tricky for me, too,' Jalen said. He placed two practice cards on a table and painted a short line on one. Tessa watched without picking up a brush. Jalen left the second card beside her and turned his own card over to try another line.
Paragraph 3. After a minute, Tessa retrieved her brush. Her first practice line wobbled. Jalen held his card beside hers, showing a blot at one end. Tessa smiled and tried again. When the coordinator asked for painters at the wall, Tessa carried both practice cards over, and Jalen brought the brushes.
She may be discouraged. She stares at a crooked line and puts down her brush before moving away; the coordinator later still needs painters at the wall.
Reasoning: First connect the crooked line to the decision to stop painting. Then check the later call for painters, which weakens the claim that the mural was finished.
Jalen 'left the second card beside her and turned his own card over to try another line.' He offers a chance to practice and lets her choose when to start.
Reasoning: First identify the offered practice card. Then notice that Jalen returns to his own work instead of issuing an order; the combination supports a gentle invitation.
Seeing Jalen's blot seems to make Tessa more willing to keep practicing despite an imperfect first line.
Reasoning: First place the smile after Jalen shows his mistake. Then connect the second attempt to renewed willingness; the story does not describe a perfect finished line.
Tessa may resume painting at the wall because she carries her practice cards there when the coordinator asks for painters.
Reasoning: First use the direction of Tessa's movement as a clue. Then make a limited prediction about returning to work, not an unsupported prediction that she will paint the entire mural alone.
Read the model-building story. Distinguish stated facts from inferences and revise claims that overreach. Acceptable answers must connect specific evidence to reasoning.
Paragraph 1. When the class opened its model bridge display, Nora set her structure behind a folded sign. One paper support had bent during cleanup. She straightened it twice, but the roadway still tilted. As families entered, she picked up her model and carried it toward the classroom's storage shelf.
Paragraph 2. Her teammate, Luis, placed their testing notes beside the empty display spot. 'The notes show what we tried,' he said. Nora looked at the pages, including the drawing of their first collapsed design. She returned with the model and moved the folded sign so the bent support was visible.
Paragraph 3. When a visitor stopped, Nora pointed to the damaged side. 'This part still needs work,' she said. 'Which of these two supports would you test next?' Soon she was writing suggestions on the back of a note page. At cleanup, she placed that page inside the model instead of putting the model on the storage shelf.
Carrying the model toward storage is a stated fact. Being reluctant to display its flaw is an inference from the folded sign, repeated straightening, and move away from the display.
Reasoning: First check whether the narrator directly describes the action. Then notice that Nora's reluctance is not named directly; readers infer it from her actions. A narrator can state feelings directly, but this passage leaves readers to work out hers.
Nora makes the bent support visible and uses the words 'This part still needs work' when speaking to a visitor. These actions show that she is now willing to discuss a flaw she first hid.
Reasoning: First choose an action and dialogue from after Luis shows the notes. Then explain the contrast with the earlier folded sign to show the change rather than merely naming it.
Luis's testing notes seem to help Nora view the unfinished model as something worth discussing and improving.
Reasoning: First remove the repair and pride claims, which are not stated or clearly established. Then link Luis's notes to Nora's return, questions, and collection of suggestions.
She likely intends to use the suggestions in later work because she saves them with the model after asking which support to test next.
Reasoning: First connect the saved page with her question about a next test. Then infer a plan to continue, while leaving open whether any future design will succeed.
Read the lesson and worked example, then try the online quiz. Original practice materials; free, with no account needed.
The PDFs contain stable Testinar website links. During this local pilot those destinations are tested on the local preview; the public links will work after an approved live release.